The Ukrainian Revolution of 1917–1921: forms of statehood (03.11.2023)
An extensive lecture-monologue by the channel’s author on the forms of statehood during the Ukrainian Revolution of 1917–1921 (in answer to a viewer’s question). Alongside the UNR, the Hetmanate and the ZUNR, it examines lesser-known state projects: the Crimean People’s Republic of the Crimean Tatars (Noman Çelebicihan), the sham Bolshevik republics (the Donetsk–Krivoy Rog one — Artyom’s “brainchild” on an economic principle, which Lenin rejected; the Taurida one — created to “cut off” Crimea from Ukraine), the Makhnovshchyna as an anarchist negation of the state, Bolbochan’s march into Crimea and the project of a “greater Ukraine within ethnic borders” at the 1919 Paris Peace Conference. It directly refutes present-day narratives of an “originally Russian Crimea” and the “DPR” as a successor to the DKR of 1918.
Key moments
- 05:53 The Crimean People's Republic; Noman Çelebicihan
- 10:23 The Donetsk–Krivoy Rog People's Republic — the brainchild of Artyom (Sergeyev)
- 11:15 Artyom: a state by economic, not national principle; Lenin against it
- 12:06 The Taurida and Odesa Soviet republics — a sham aimed against Ukraine
- 41:01 Makhno — an anarchist; he fought against all states and built none of his own
- 49:26 The map of a "greater Ukraine" — a project of the UNR delegation to the 1919 Paris Conference
- 51:38 The Central Rada made no claim to Crimea (the Third Universal — without Crimea)
- 52:22 Bolbochan's march into Crimea in 1918; the verbal order of Zhukovskyi
- 54:00 The Kuban People's Republic