Did a Muscovite state exist? (the "History of Russia" series, 28.03.2026)

Date
28 March 2026
Duration
13:51
Platform
YouTube

An author’s monologue (in Ukrainian, with direct quotations in the original Russian) — an analysis of the newest multi-volume academic edition “History of Russia” (published from 2024). The author reads out the introduction to the 4th volume (“Russia in the 10th century”, p. 28), in which the Russian publishers themselves admit that the 10th-century state is called, in the scholarly literature and in the sources, “Russian”, “Muscovite” and “Rossian” alike — and use these names “как синонимы, не вкладывая никакого иного смысла” (as synonyms, without attaching any other meaning to them). This is strong evidence that official Russian historiography has no continuous name “Russia” from Rus’. A source for the article “How ‘Rus” became ‘Russia’”.

Key moments

  1. 00:18 The multi-volume "History of Russia" (published from 2024), volume 4 — "Russia in the 10th century"
  2. 01:11 A quotation from the introduction to vol. 4 (p. 28): the 10th-c. state is called "Russian", "Muscovite" and "Rossian" alike
  3. 02:13 "We use them as synonyms" — the official edition acknowledges the synonymy of the names
  4. 06:23 P. 117: the self-name "Muscovite state"; 1547 — the "Rossian tsardom"
  5. 09:57 Ivan IV's title "tsar of all Rus'/Rossiya" — dynastic claims, not realities

Topics from this source