Is Ukraine a 'Nazi State'?
The myth
“Denazification” is the word with which the Kremlin designated one of the goals of the invasion. Behind it stands the thesis that Ukraine is a Nazi state, governed by Nazis, and therefore requires “cleansing” from outside. This is a claim about the state: about its system, its law, and its official ideology. It is precisely at this level that it should be tested — and it is precisely here that it falls apart.
The fact: Nazism is banned by law
Ukrainian legislation contains a direct ban on Nazi (and communist) symbols and propaganda[1]. It was introduced by a law adopted on 9 April 2015 as part of the decommunization package. Under it, one may not publicly display the symbols of either regime, perform their anthems, or name streets and squares after their figures[2]. The Constitutional Court of Ukraine subsequently found this law to be in conformity with the Constitution.
Precision of wording matters here. To equate two regimes in a ban does not mean to declare them identical; it means that both are placed outside the law[2]. A state cannot simultaneously ban Nazism by law and be Nazi — this is a direct logical contradiction.
Why both regimes in particular are banned
The ban is not symmetrical by accident — it has a historical basis. The Ukrainian people suffered from both totalitarianisms: from the communist one (the famine of 1921–23, the Holodomor of 1932–33, the postwar famine of 1946–47, decades of repression) and from the Nazi one (the German occupation brought mass death)[3]. That is why the state condemns and bans both ideologies — as two experiences of the extermination of its own population, not one.
What this means
The accusation of “state Nazism” is easy to check at the level of the state — by its laws. And they say the opposite: Nazi ideology and symbols in Ukraine are banned, on a par with the communist ones. Attempts to save the thesis by shifting the dispute to individual historical figures or symbols do not save it: they no longer concern the system of the state but assessments of the past — a separate and complex question that does not make present-day Ukraine “Nazi.” The “denazification” of a country where Nazism is banned by law is not a goal but a propaganda cover for aggression.
Related persons
- Vitaliy Dribnytsya — Historian, author of the 'Vox Veritatis' channel
References
- [1] paraphrase
В законе у нас запрет нацистской и коммунистической символики и пропаганды.
Back to text - [2] summary
По законодательству Украины нельзя демонстрировать нацистскую и коммунистическую символику, нельзя называть площади и улицы именами нацистов и коммунистов. Приравняли и запретили — это не значит, что коммунизм и нацизм одно и то же, это значит, что и то, и другое запрещено.
Back to text - [3] summary
Украинский народ пострадал и от коммунизма (голод 1921–23, 1932–33, 1946–47 годов, репрессии), и от нацизма: когда немцы заняли Украину, они принесли смерть. Поэтому в Украине запрещена и нацистская, и коммунистическая символика и идеология.
Back to text
Sources
- document (2015) Law 'On the Condemnation of the Communist and National Socialist (Nazi) Totalitarian Regimes in Ukraine and the Prohibition of Propaganda of Their Symbols' (No. 317-VIII) Adopted on 9 April 2015 (the decommunization package). It bans the production and public use of the symbols of the communist and Nazi regimes and the propaganda of both. The Constitutional Court of Ukraine found the law to be in conformity with the Constitution.